Create your own deli style sandwich!
All come with fresh tomato, lettuce, onion, cheddar & provolone cheeses, mayo, mustard, (want chipotle mayo or ranch? ask us to substitute!), & pickle spears
Kettle chips $1.50/person
Coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni pasta salad, italian pasta salad, or fresh fruit $2.75 ea/person
* Choose three premium deli meats or veggies (we slice all meats/veggies in shop to order):
Antibiotic and certified gluten free roasted turkey, black forest ham, roast beef, pastrami, herb roasted chicken, chicken salad, tuna salad, egg salad, fresh veggies
*Choose two kinds of bread or wraps:
Sourdough, multi grain, light rye, herb focaccia, or wraps. Gluten free bread and wraps are both available $1.50/person.
It's not just a taco bar anymore! We have plenty of options to mix things up!
*Choose your two bases: soft flour shells, cruncy corn shell, soft corn shells, crunchy tostadas, Fritos, or Doritos (chips come in individual bags to make real walking tacos!)
*Choose two proteins: seasoned ground beef, pork carnitas, shredded beef barbacoa, mesquite chicken, chipotle chicken, chorizo sausage, grilled veggies(mushrooms, peppers, onions)
*Choose two: white rice, cilantro lime rice, black beans, pinto beans, or refried beans
*All come with shredded lettuce, monteray jack cheese, sour cream
*Choose one salsa: traditional tomato, green chile, Two Tall citrus gin & cucumber, Two Tall whisky black bean & corn
ADD A SECOND $2.00/PERSON
GUACAMOLE OR AVOCADO CREAM
TORTILLA CHIPS & SALSA $1.75/PERSON
NACHO CHEESE OR QUESO SAUCE
*comes with two pastas, two sauces, two proteins, caesar salad, parmesan, & garlic breadsticks or garlic bread
PASTA: Penne, Cavatappi, Farfalle, Spaghtetti
*Gluten free pasta available $2.00/person
PROTEIN: Meatballs, Italian Sausage, Sliced Grilled Chicken, Sliced Breaded Chicken, or Garden Veggies
SAUCE: chunky marinara, traditional meat sauce, garlic alfredo, pesto marinara, pesto alfredo, or garlic butter scampi, mac n cheese sauce, firehouse cheese sauce(mix of grand cru, smoked fontina, & chile pepper gouda)
**SUBSTITUTE A PASTA FOR A BAKED PASTA DISH $1.50/PERSON:
baked spaghetti with chunky marinara & mozzarella cheese on top, meat lasagna with red sauce, chicken lasagna with white sauce, or garden veggie lasagna with white sauce
Buffets & Bars
WE CAN WORK WITH YOU TO INDIVIDUALLY PACKAGE THESE BUFFETS!!
Please provide minimum of a two day notice. We will deliver (fee may apply) & set up!
We also provide all plates, bowls, utensils, & napkins at no extra charge!
Let us work with you to create a custom bar menu! We'll figure out what it is you're looking for, your budget, and how many people and create it to fit your needs! Just give us a call or email and we'll gladly help!
Both styles of gyros come with one side:
kettle chips, potato salad, coleslaw, or
macaroni pasta salad
Traditional Gyro: $9.00/person
Athen's Gyro lamb and beef meat, diced tomatos, sliced onions, shredded lettuce,
tzatziki sauce, & warm pitas
Chicken Gyro: $9.75/person shredded chicken marinated in garlic, lemon, & seasonings, then grilled, served with tzatziki sauce, medley of cucumbers, tomatoes, onion, and spinach all on the side & warm pitas
**SUBSTITUTE HALF PITAS FOR FRESH MIXED GREENS TO OFFER A GYRO SALAD**
Choose one gourmet hot sandwich:
(add a second for $3.00/person)
Italian Beef with sauteed peppers & onions,
& provolone cheese on a hoagie bun.
Grilled or Breaded Chicken Breast on
choice of a brioche bun, ciabatta
or pretzel bun.
Cheddar, lettuce, tomato, & onion served
on the side.
Choose two dressings: mayo, chipotle mayo, ranch, dijon mustard, BBQ, or honey mustard
Grilled Chicken Teriyaki on choice of a brioche bun or ciabatta bun. Grilled chicken marinated in teriyaki sauce served with grilled brown sugar pineapple slices, lettuce, & onion on the side.
Italian Chicken Parmesan on choice of a brioche bun or ciabatta bun. Breaded chicken breast in chunky marinara sauce, served with pepperoni, mozzarella, & grilled peppers and onions on the side.
Shredded Roast Beef on choice of a brioche bun or ciabatta bun. Tender roast beef shredded and served in homemade beef gravy. Comes with grilled onions, cheddar, & pickle slices on the side.
All come with one side (add a second for $2.50/person):
A customer favorite at various events we've sold it at over the years and our previous cafe! Tim slow cooks both the pulled pork and mesquite chicken in house! Highly recommend trying this!
All come with pickle spears & you choose the rest!
*Choose your protein: pulled pork or mesquite chicken HAVE BOTH FOR EXRA $2.50/PERSON
*Choose your bread/bun: pretzel bun, brioche bun, potato bun, or cornbread
Gluten free bread $1.50/person
*Choose two sauces: traditional sweet & tangy, apple bacon, Door County cherry chipotle, honey bourbon, beer & sriracha, or
spicy habanero with pineapple
*Choose one sides: coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni pasta salad, hot cheesy potatoes, or kettle chips.
ADD ANOTHER SIDE $2.50/PERSON
comes with broccoli, cheese sauce, bacon, chicken, green onions, sour cream, butter, & garlic bread, our house salad with dressing.
Add our homemade beef or vegetarian chili
SUBSITUTE HALF YOUR BAKED POTATOES FOR TATOR TOTS (SAME PRICE)
OR SWEET POTATOES $1.50/PERSON
Comes with 8 oz chili per person, oyster crackers, choice of garlic bread, Frito's, or cornbread, & a house salad with dressing.
Choice of two of our homemade chili's:
Beef, Vegetarian, White Chicken with Green Chile, Cowboy BBQ Pulled Pork, or
Taco Beef Chili
Served with toppings on the side: sour cream, shredded cheddar cheese, diced onions, &
hot sauce, & macaroni pasta.